Misdiagnosis of Carrie Buck, Paul Lombardo

Interviewee: Paul Lombardo. Emma and Carrie Buck lived long lives and it is doubtful that either was mentally ill. (DNAi Location: Chronicle > Trial of Carrie Buck > Players > Emma Buck > Were they feebleminded? )

Carrie was examined by doctors who claimed that she was feebleminded, but that term didn't have too much meaning in 1924. Emma also went through certain tests and was considered somehow "defective," to use the language of the day. But it's unlikely that either of them had any serious mental illnesses or other problems. More than their mental state, their moral state is at issue here. They were considered people who had sex too often, with the wrong people. They were considered loose women. It turns out that Carrie was actually assaulted, and that was the reason she got pregnant. We know less about Emma, but we know in both cases that they lived relatively long lives, with no real indication that they were mentally ill or retarded.

carrie buck,charlottesville virginia,mental illnesses,virginia paul,dnai,moral state,loose women,misdiagnosis,interviewee,lombardo,sterilization,emma,doctors

Related Content

15206. Forced sterilization, Paul Lombardo

mma and Carrie Buck were committed to the Virginia Colony because they were unmarried mothers and were considered morally delinquent.

  • ID: 15206
  • Source: DNAi

15208. Carrie Buck before the trial, Paul Lombardo

Paul Lombardo discussed Carrie Buck's state of mind before the Buck vs. Bell trial.

  • ID: 15208
  • Source: DNAi

15222. Photo of Carrie Buck and her mother, Paul Lombardo

Paul Lombardo talks about the only photograph of Carrie Buck with her mother Emma, taken the day before she would stand trial before the collective onslaught of the American eugenics movement.

  • ID: 15222
  • Source: DNAi

15217. How Buck vs. Bell began, Paul Lombardo

Paul Lombardo talks about Amherst County Courthouse was the first step of a legal case that would lead all the way to the Supreme Court.

  • ID: 15217
  • Source: DNAi

15226. Twisting the truth at Buck vs. Bell, Paul Lombardo

Paul Lombardo talks about twisting the truth at Buck vs. Bell.

  • ID: 15226
  • Source: DNAi

15207. Discussion of the photo of Carrie and Emma Buck, Paul Lombardo

Lombardo discusses the emotions that Carrie Buck may have been feeling before the Buck vs. Bell trial.

  • ID: 15207
  • Source: DNAi

15216. The death of Emma Buck, Paul Lombardo

Paul Lombardo talks about although she tried several times, Carrie was never able to bring her mother Emma home from the Virginia Colony.

  • ID: 15216
  • Source: DNAi

15540. Carrie Buck and Emma Buck

Carrie and Emma Buck on the day before the Buck vs. Bell trial in 1924.

  • ID: 15540
  • Source: DNAi

15757. Emma Buck's gravestone

Emma Buck's gravestone

  • ID: 15757
  • Source: DNAi

15209. Carrie and Emma Buck the day before the trial, Paul Lombardo

Paul Lombardo discusses Carrie and Emma Buck's state of mind prior to the Buck vs. Bell trial.

  • ID: 15209
  • Source: DNAi