Why Asilomar conference was a bad idea, Victor McElheny

Interviewee: Victor McElheny. Former New York Times science journalist Victor McElheny talks about why he thought the "Moratorium Letter" was asking for trouble. (DNAi Location: Manipulation > Revolution > Players > The controversy > Why the moratorium was a disaster)

Because I thought it invited thunderbolts from heaven. The world is an irrational place and I reported about science, in part I think by an idealistic devotion to science as the only rational raft that we can be on. And here we were about to dash a lot of quite realistic hopes with ill-informed political and public interference. I knew the letter would give rise to a sort of fire-storm of ill-informed brave new world stuff.

asilomar conference,public interference,science journalist,recombinant dna,times science,dnai,fire storm,new york times,interviewee,brave new world,moratorium,bad idea,raft,devotion,manipulation,controversy,disaster,heaven

Related Content

15135. Reaction of young scientists to Asilomar, Victor McElheny

Former New York Times journalist Victor McElheny remembers the fears of young scientists.

  • ID: 15133
  • Type: video
  • Source: DNAi

15137. Asilomar as a poor model for the interaction of science and society, Victor McElheny

Former science journalist Victor McElheny talks about why the Asilomar conference is not a good model for the interaction of science and society.

  • ID: 15133
  • Type: video
  • Source: DNAi

15134. The exciting thing about recombinant DNA, Victor McElheny

Former science journalist Victor McElheny muses on the excitement that surrounded the new genetic technology.

  • ID: 15133
  • Type: video
  • Source: DNAi

15136. Attempting the impossible at Asilomar, Victor McElheny

Former science journalist Victor McElheny talks about the impossible task of reconciling science and society in a week.

  • ID: 15133
  • Type: video
  • Source: DNAi

15654. Asilomar conference papers

"Asilomar Conference on Recombinant DNA Molecules" published in Science on June 6, 1975.

  • ID: 15133
  • Type: video
  • Source: DNAi

15423. Initial feelings on Asilomar meeting, James Watson

James Watson recollects his feelings about the Asilomar meeting.

  • ID: 15133
  • Type: video
  • Source: DNAi

15021. The moratorium letter regarding risky experiments, Paul Berg

In 1974, scientists in the field of recombinant DNA drafted a letter calling upon "scientists throughout the world" to suspend certain types of studies until hazards could be assessed. Paul Berg talks about the "Moratorium Letter."

  • ID: 15133
  • Type: video
  • Source: DNAi

15204. Squandering the lessons of Asilomar, Alexander Capron

Concerned lawyer Alexander Capron talks about what was learned at Asilomar.

  • ID: 15133
  • Type: video
  • Source: DNAi

15031. Feelings at Asilomar meeting, Herbert Boyer

Biotech pioneer Herb Boyer recounts how he felt at the Asilomar meeting.

  • ID: 15133
  • Type: video
  • Source: DNAi

15424. Reflecting on Asilomar meeting, James Watson

More than 25 years after the historic meeting, James Watson looks back.

  • ID: 15133
  • Type: video
  • Source: DNAi